- Free Consultation: 617-263-6800 Tap Here To Call Us
Massachusetts Prostitution Charges Dismissed Against Retired Military Veteran
Attorney Stephen Neyman successfully defended a retired military veteran with 42 years of military service who faced serious prostitution-related criminal charges in Massachusetts. The Commonwealth charged our client with procuring a person to practice prostitution in violation of G.L. c. 272, § 12, and deriving support from a prostitute, a felony under G.L. c. 272, § 7.
After approximately one year of litigation and preparation for trial, both charges were dismissed. Despite an extensive police investigation involving undercover operations, surveillance, interviews with more than 20 alleged customers, and the execution of a search warrant, the prosecution faced significant evidentiary obstacles in attempting to prove the charges.
The Prostitution Investigation and Criminal Charges
Our client was a retired military veteran who had dedicated 42 years of his life to serving this country. The Commonwealth alleged that beginning in 2024, he and his co-defendant and business partner had been operating a house of prostitution under the guise of a massage parlor and bodyworks facility.
An incident involving the death of a customer brought the establishment to the attention of law enforcement, prompting an investigation into its operations.
During the investigation, police learned that the business did not have a license for massage therapy. Officers also monitored advertisements offering sexual services that they believed were connected to the establishment.
Police subsequently conducted an undercover operation. An undercover officer entered the business posing as a customer while other officers called the establishment. The undercover officer was able to identify the incoming telephone number, which investigators used to connect the business to the advertisements.
The investigation continued. Police determined that our client and his partner owned the business. Officers conducted surveillance and identified individuals who had visited the establishment through motor vehicle registration records.
Investigators ultimately interviewed more than 20 alleged customers. Almost all reportedly admitted to purchasing sexual services at the establishment.
Armed with the information gathered during the investigation, police obtained a search warrant and searched the business. Officers located items they believed corroborated statements made by the individuals they had interviewed.
The investigation ultimately resulted in our client being charged with two serious offenses:
- Procuring a person to practice prostitution, in violation of G.L. c. 272, § 12.
- Deriving support from a prostitute, in violation of G.L. c. 272, § 7.
Attorney Stephen Neyman was retained to defend our client against these allegations.
The Defense Strategy: Challenging the Commonwealth’s Evidence
Although the police investigation was extensive, the defense identified substantial problems with the Commonwealth’s ability to prove the charged offenses at trial.
An important distinction in this case was that proving prostitution allegedly occurred at the establishment was not necessarily sufficient to establish that our client committed either of the crimes with which he was charged.
The prosecution still had to prove the specific legal elements of each offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
1. Problems With Calling the Alleged Customers as Witnesses
A significant portion of the Commonwealth’s investigation depended on statements obtained from individuals who allegedly purchased sexual services at the establishment.
However, these individuals could potentially expose themselves to criminal liability by testifying about their own alleged conduct. As a result, the defense recognized that calling these individuals as witnesses could present substantial Fifth Amendment privilege issues.
The prosecution’s ability to establish what actually occurred at the business could therefore be complicated by the potential unavailability of critical witnesses.
2. The Alleged Prostitutes Had Not Been Identified
Another significant weakness involved the identities of the individuals whom the Commonwealth alleged were providing sexual services.
The discovery materials identified two alleged prostitutes, but did not establish their identities or provide information sufficient to locate them. The defense believed that law enforcement had not established their true identities or addresses.
This created an additional evidentiary obstacle for the prosecution, particularly in attempting to establish the allegations underlying the charge of procuring a person to practice prostitution.
3. Lack of Evidence That Our Client Procured the Services of Another Person
Under G.L. c. 272, § 12, the Commonwealth had to establish the elements of the specific offense charged, including our client’s knowing involvement in procuring, enticing, sending, or aiding or abetting the procurement, enticement, or sending of a person to practice prostitution.
The defense maintained that the Commonwealth lacked witnesses and sufficient evidence to establish that our client personally engaged in the conduct necessary to support this charge.
Evidence suggesting that prostitution might have occurred at a business does not automatically establish that its owner committed the separate offense of procuring another person to practice prostitution.
4. Lack of Evidence Supporting the Charge of Deriving Support From a Prostitute
The defense also challenged the Commonwealth’s ability to prove the charge under G.L. c. 272, § 7.
Even if the prosecution could establish that prostitution occurred at the establishment, it still had to prove the additional elements of deriving support from or sharing in the earnings or proceeds of prostitution.
The defense maintained that the Commonwealth lacked sufficient evidence to establish that our client knowingly derived support from the prostitution of another person or shared in the earnings or proceeds as required by the statute.
This was an important distinction because ownership of a business, standing alone, does not establish every element of a prostitution-related criminal offense.
The Outcome: Both Prostitution-Related Charges Dismissed
After approximately one year of litigation, Attorney Stephen Neyman and our office elected to push the case toward trial.
Although the investigation involved substantial police resources and numerous interviews, the defense believed that the Commonwealth would have significant difficulty establishing the essential elements of the two charged offenses.
As the prosecution prepared for trial, the evidentiary problems became increasingly significant. Ultimately, the Commonwealth dismissed both charges.
Our client avoided a criminal conviction on these serious prostitution-related Massachusetts sex crimes allegations.
Massachusetts Prostitution Charges Require a Strong Defense
This case illustrates an important principle in Massachusetts criminal defense: an extensive police investigation does not necessarily mean that the Commonwealth can prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.
Even when police conduct undercover operations, interview numerous witnesses, perform surveillance, and obtain search warrants, the prosecution must still establish every required element of the charged offenses.
Attorney Stephen Neyman represents individuals facing serious criminal allegations throughout Massachusetts, including prostitution-related offenses and other sex crimes.
If you are facing prostitution charges or another serious sex crime allegation in Massachusetts, contact our office to discuss your legal options.











